Sullivan’s Steakhouse Naperville: Fine Dining Near the Riverwalk (2025 Guide)

When you’re searching for an upscale dining experience in downtown Naperville, Sullivan’s Steakhouse i delivers the complete package: hand-cut steaks, an extensive wine program, live music, and an atmosphere that transforms a regular dinner into a memorable evening. Located steps from the Naperville Riverwalk, Sullivan’s has been Naperville’s go-to destination for celebrations, date nights, and business dinners since 1999.

This guide covers everything you need to know before visiting Sullivan’s—from their signature dishes and wine selection to private event options and what makes this steakhouse a downtown Naperville institution.

Quick Answer for Naperville Diners: Sullivan’s Steakhouse specializes in premium hand-cut steaks (including A5 Japanese Wagyu and dry-aged ribeye), serves over 240 wines with two sommeliers on staff, features nightly live music in the bar area, and offers three private event spaces. Reservations are recommended for Friday and Saturday evenings. Located at 244 S Main Street, downtown Naperville.

Welcome to Sullivan’s Steakhouse

Upon entering Sullivan’s, you’re greeted with a warm atmosphere that sets the tone for an unforgettable dining experience. The restaurant is buzzing with energy, especially during dinner shifts, which only adds to the excitement of your meal.

Location & Atmosphere: Downtown Naperville’s Premier Steakhouse

Sullivan’s Steakhouse sits in the heart of downtown Naperville at 244 S Main Street, placing you within a five-minute walk of the Naperville Riverwalk, Centennial Beach, and dozens of boutique shops along Washington Street. If you’re exploring downtown before or after dinner, there’s ample parking in the nearby Van Buren Street Parking Deck or metered street parking along Main Street.

Step inside and you’ll immediately notice the energy. The dining room hums with conversation, especially during weekend dinner service, while the bar area pulses with live music Thursday through Saturday nights. The space strikes a balance between upscale elegance and approachable warmth—dimmed lighting, dark wood accents, white tablecloths, and enough buzz to feel like you’re part of something special without sacrificing the ability to have a conversation.

Sullivan’s occupies a unique position in Naperville’s dining scene. While the western suburbs offer plenty of chain steakhouses, Sullivan’s combines premium ingredients with a commitment to personalized service that keeps locals returning for anniversaries, graduations, and milestone celebrations year after year.

The Wine Program: 240+ Bottles From Around the World

One of Sullivan’s most impressive features is the wine list. With over 240 selections spanning Napa Valley, Bordeaux, Tuscany, Chile, and even Germany, the restaurant takes its beverage program seriously. Two certified sommeliers work the floor nightly, ready to guide guests through pairings whether you’re ordering a $40 bottle or splurging on a collector’s reserve.

Standout Selection: Sullivan’s Private Label Cabernet from Napa Valley consistently earns praise from both casual wine drinkers and enthusiasts. Priced reasonably by the glass or bottle, it pairs beautifully with any of their beef cuts especially the dry-aged ribeye. The sommeliers describe it as approachable yet layered, with dark fruit notes and a smooth finish that won’t overpower your steak.

For guests intimidated by extensive wine lists, the sommeliers offer a straightforward approach: tell them what you’re ordering and whether you prefer bold or lighter reds (or whites if you’re going with seafood), and they’ll narrow it down to two or three strong options. This personal touch turns what could be an overwhelming decision into part of the experience.

Sullivan’s also rotates seasonal wine features and hosts periodic tasting events for wine club members—ask your server about upcoming dates if you’re interested in exploring beyond your usual preferences.

Signature Starters Worth Ordering

While steaks command the spotlight, Sullivan’s appetizers deserve attention—particularly the Philly Cheesesteak Egg Rolls, which have developed a cult following among Naperville regulars.

Philly Cheesesteak Egg Rolls
These aren’t standard egg rolls. Sullivan’s fills wonton wrappers with hand-cut ribeye steak, white American cheese, and caramelized onions, then fries them until the exterior shatters with each bite. They arrive at your table with both a sweet chili glaze and honey mustard for dipping. The combination of textures—crispy shell, tender beef, melted cheese—makes them dangerously addictive. Order one for the table, but don’t be surprised if you want a second round.

Other popular starters include:

• Lobster Bisque: Rich and creamy with generous chunks of lobster
• Wedge Salad: Iceberg lettuce, bacon, tomatoes, and blue cheese dressing
• Ahi Tuna: Seared rare with Asian-inspired accompaniments

The portions are generous enough to share, though if you’re planning on a full steak dinner, consider splitting one or two appetizers rather than ordering individually.

Refreshing Specialty Drinks

At Sullivan’s, the drink menu is just as impressive as the food. One standout is the Knockout cocktail, made from sweet Hawaiian pineapples and orange vodka that are infused together for 14 days. This unique process results in a refreshing and delicious drink that has no added sugars or syrups. It’s a refreshing choice that pairs well with your meal.

Private Events: Celebrate in Style

Sullivan’s also caters to those looking to host private events. With three private rooms that can accommodate between 8 to 75 guests, it’s the perfect spot for graduations, baby showers, and other celebrations. The restaurant’s commitment to building personal relationships with guests makes every event feel special and memorable.

The Atmosphere: Live Music and More

The lively atmosphere at Sullivan’s is complemented by live music, especially in the bar area. This creates a vibrant pulse that enhances the dining experience. Guests can enjoy cocktails and appetizers while soaking in the energetic vibe before sitting down for a full meal.

Exceptional Cuts: What to Order at Sullivan’s

Sullivan’s built its reputation on steak, and the kitchen doesn’t take shortcuts. Every cut is hand-selected, aged in-house (for dry-aged selections), and cooked to your exact specifications.

The Core Lineup:

• Filet Mignon (8 oz or 12 oz): Butter-tender, the leanest option
• New York Strip (14 oz): Balance of marbling and texture
• Dry-Aged Ribeye (16 oz): Maximum flavor, beautifully marbled
• Bone-In Kansas City Strip (20 oz): For serious appetites
• A5 Japanese Wagyu (market price): The pinnacle of beef luxury

Seasonal Special to Watch For:
Sullivan’s occasionally runs a 32-ounce Australian Wagyu special paired with twin lobster tails and a bottle of wine at a package price that’s genuinely competitive for the quality. If you’re celebrating something significant or dining with a fellow steak enthusiast, this combination delivers an unforgettable meal.

Each steak arrives on a sizzling hot plate (be careful when the server warns you). Sides are ordered separately, and the roasted garlic mashed potatoes and grilled asparagus are consistent favorites that complement rather than compete with the beef.

Pro tip from regulars: If you’re torn between cuts, ask your server which steaks were freshly cut that day. The staff can guide you toward whatever’s in peak condition.

Creating an Unexpected Experience

Sullivan’s Steakhouse has been a staple in Naperville since 1999, and its longevity can be attributed to its commitment to delivering an unexpected experience. The team aims to exceed every guest’s expectations, whether through exceptional service, high-quality food, or the overall ambiance of the restaurant.

Specialty Cocktails & The Bar Scene {#drinks}

Sullivan’s bar operates as its own destination within the restaurant. During weekends, many guests start their evening at the bar with cocktails and appetizers before moving to the dining room—or they skip a table reservation altogether and dine at the bar.

The Knockout Cocktail
This signature drink showcases Sullivan’s attention to craft. Bartenders infuse sweet Hawaiian pineapple and orange vodka together for 14 days, creating a spirit base that needs no added syrups or artificial sweeteners. The result is a refreshing, naturally sweet cocktail that drinks dangerously easy while packing serious flavor. It’s become popular enough that guests often order it throughout their meal rather than just as an aperitif.

The bar also features rotating seasonal cocktails, classic martinis (dirty or dry), and an Old Fashioned program that allows you to select your preferred whiskey.

Live Music Schedule:
Thursday through Saturday nights, Sullivan’s brings in live musicians who perform in the bar area. The music leans toward jazz, blues, and classic rock—volume levels that enhance the atmosphere without making conversation difficult. If you prefer a quieter experience, request a table in the main dining room away from the bar when making reservations.

Private Events: Celebrations Done Right {#events}

Sullivan’s maintains three private dining rooms that can accommodate groups ranging from intimate gatherings of 8 to larger celebrations of 75 guests. The restaurant has hosted everything from rehearsal dinners and milestone birthdays to corporate dinners and baby showers.

What Sets Sullivan’s Private Events Apart:
The team takes a relationship-driven approach to event planning. When you book a private room, you’re assigned a dedicated event coordinator who works with you on menu selection, wine pairings, room setup, and any special requests (custom menus, dietary accommodations, A/V needs for presentations). This personalized attention ensures your event reflects your vision rather than feeling like a cookie-cutter experience.

Private dining menus can be customized but typically include options for prix fixe multi-course meals or family-style service for larger groups. If you’re planning a Naperville event and want a venue that handles both food quality and service execution, Sullivan’s deserves consideration.

Booking Timeline:
For popular dates (graduation weekends, holidays, Saturday evenings in spring and fall), book at least 6-8 weeks in advance. Sullivan’s can often accommodate last-minute requests for midweek events or smaller groups with shorter notice.

Why Sullivan’s Has Lasted 25+ Years in Naperville {#reputation}

Since opening in downtown Naperville in 1999, Sullivan’s has maintained its position as the suburb’s premier steakhouse through consistent execution and a genuine commitment to guest experience. In a market where restaurants come and go, longevity matters—especially for special occasion dining where you’re investing both money and memories.

What Keeps Locals Returning:

• Consistency: Order the same dish on separate visits and you’ll get the same quality
• Staff Tenure: Many servers and bartenders have worked at Sullivan’s for years, creating genuine relationships with regular guests
• Quality Over Trends: While the menu evolves, Sullivan’s doesn’t chase fads—they focus on executing steakhouse fundamentals at a high level
• Downtown Location: The Riverwalk proximity and walkable downtown setting make Sullivan’s part of a complete Naperville evening

The restaurant has earned features in local and regional publications, but perhaps more telling are the Naperville families who return for the same celebration year after year—the anniversary couple who sits at the same booth, the family who books a private room for graduations, the business executives who close deals over ribeyes and wine.

Dining Tips & Reservation Recommendations {#tips}

Best Times to Visit:

• Weekday Evenings (Tuesday-Thursday): Easier reservations, full menu, slightly quieter atmosphere
• Friday-Saturday Nights: Peak energy, live music, full bar scene—reserve 2+ weeks ahead
• Sunday Evenings: Good option for special occasion dinners with less weekend chaos

Parking:
Use the Van Buren Street Parking Deck (152 Van Buren Ave) or the Water Street Parking Deck. Both are within a 3-minute walk. Street parking along Main Street and Washington Street is metered but often full during dinner hours.

Dress Code:
Business casual to dressy. You’ll see everything from sport coats to dress jeans, but Sullivan’s skews more formal than casual.

Budget Expectations:
Plan $75-150 per person including appetizer, entree, sides, and drinks. The price reflects the quality—this isn’t a casual dinner spot.

Reservations:
Strongly recommended for all nights, required for weekends. Call (630) 305-0230 or book through their website or OpenTable.

Conclusion: A Must-Visit Naperville Steakhouse

If you’re looking for a memorable dining experience in Naperville, Sullivan’s Steakhouse should be at the top of your list. With its outstanding steaks, vast wine selection, and inviting atmosphere, it truly represents the best of what a steakhouse can offer. Whether you’re celebrating a special occasion or just enjoying a night out, Sullivan’s promises an experience that will leave you satisfied and eager to return.

FAQs about Sullivan’s Steakhouse

What type of cuisine does Sullivan’s Steakhouse offer?

Sullivan’s specializes in premium hand-cut steaks aged in-house, with additional menu options including fresh seafood (lobster tails, Chilean sea bass, ahi tuna), chicken, lamb chops, and chef-selected appetizers. The wine program features 240+ selections from around the world.

Do they have options for private events?

Yes, Sullivan’s offers three private dining rooms accommodating 8 to 75 guests for events including rehearsal dinners, corporate gatherings, milestone celebrations, graduations, and baby showers. A dedicated event coordinator assists with menu planning and customization.

What is the most popular drink at Sullivan’s?

The Knockout cocktail made with Hawaiian pineapple and orange vodka infused together for 14 days—is one of Sullivan’s signature drinks. The restaurant also features two sommeliers who can recommend wine pairings from their 240+ bottle selection.

How extensive is the wine selection at Sullivan’s?

Sullivan’s offers over 240 wines, with a Private Label Cabernet from Napa Valley as well as selections from around the world.

Are there live music performances at Sullivan’s?

Yes, Sullivan’s features live music in the bar area, enhancing the dining experience with a vibrant atmosphere.

Subscribe to our YouTube Channel for all things Naperville and real estate. From local Business Highlights, upcoming events, to expert real estate tips, we’ve got the latest updates and stories that matter to you.

Get Your Business Featured on Naperville.com

We’ll create a professionally edited video showcasing your business and feature it on our Youtube channel, Naperville.com, along with social media promotion, and more! It’s the perfect way to get notice in the Naperville community.